Skip to main content

Main navigation

  • About BCS
    • Mission
    • History
    • Building 46
      • Building 46 Room Reservations
    • Leadership
    • Employment
    • Contact
      • BCS Spot Awards
      • Building 46 Email and Slack
    • Directory
  • Faculty + Research
    • Faculty
    • Areas of Research
    • Postdoctoral Research
      • Postdoctoral Association and Committees
    • Core Facilities
    • InBrain
      • InBRAIN Collaboration Data Sharing Policy
  • Academics
    • Course 9: Brain and Cognitive Sciences
    • Course 6-9: Computation and Cognition
      • Course 6-9 MEng
    • Brain and Cognitive Sciences PhD
      • How to Apply
      • Program Details
      • Classes
      • Research
      • Student Life
      • For Current Students
    • Molecular and Cellular Neuroscience Program
      • How to Apply to MCN
      • MCN Faculty and Research Areas
      • MCN Curriculum
      • Model Systems
      • MCN Events
      • MCN FAQ
      • MCN Contacts
    • Computationally-Enabled Integrative Neuroscience Program
    • Research Scholars Program
    • Course Offerings
  • News + Events
    • News
    • Events
    • Recordings
    • Newsletter
  • Community + Culture
    • Community + Culture
    • Community Stories
    • Outreach
      • MIT Summer Research Program (MSRP)
      • Post-Baccalaureate Research Scholars
      • Conferences, Outreach and Networking Opportunities
    • Get Involved (MIT login required)
    • Resources (MIT login Required)
  • Give to BCS
    • Join the Champions of the Brain Fellows Society
    • Meet Our Donors

Utility Menu

  • Directory
  • Apply to BCS
  • Contact Us

Footer

  • Contact Us
  • Employment
  • Be a Test Subject
  • Login

Footer 2

  • McGovern
  • Picower

Utility Menu

  • Directory
  • Apply to BCS
  • Contact Us
Brain and Cognitive Sciences
Menu
MIT

Main navigation

  • About BCS
    • Mission
    • History
    • Building 46
    • Leadership
    • Employment
    • Contact
    • Directory
  • Faculty + Research
    • Faculty
    • Areas of Research
    • Postdoctoral Research
    • Core Facilities
    • InBrain
  • Academics
    • Course 9: Brain and Cognitive Sciences
    • Course 6-9: Computation and Cognition
    • Brain and Cognitive Sciences PhD
    • Molecular and Cellular Neuroscience Program
    • Computationally-Enabled Integrative Neuroscience Program
    • Research Scholars Program
    • Course Offerings
  • News + Events
    • News
    • Events
    • Recordings
    • Newsletter
  • Community + Culture
    • Community + Culture
    • Community Stories
    • Outreach
    • Get Involved (MIT login required)
    • Resources (MIT login Required)
  • Give to BCS
    • Join the Champions of the Brain Fellows Society
    • Meet Our Donors

Events

News Menu

  • News
  • Events
  • Newsletters

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Events
  3. A mental forward model for error monitoring during motor planning | Representations of time-dependent behavior in working memory
Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences (BCS)
Cog Lunch

A mental forward model for error monitoring during motor planning | Representations of time-dependent behavior in working memory

Speaker(s)
Nicolas Meirhaeghe
Eli Pollock
Add to CalendarAmerica/New_YorkA mental forward model for error monitoring during motor planning | Representations of time-dependent behavior in working memory04/17/2018 4:00 pm04/17/2018 5:00 pmMcGovern Seminar Room (46-3189)
April 17, 2018
4:00 pm - 5:00 pm
Location
McGovern Seminar Room (46-3189)
Contact
Matthew Regan
    Description

    A mental forward model for error monitoring during motor planning

     

    Nicolas Meirhaeghe

    PhD Candidate

    Harvard-MIT Division of Health Sciences and Technology, Bioastronautics Training Program

     

    Because movements are inherently variable, even the simplest action can deviate from what was originally intended. This poses a fundamental question: to what extent do we/can we evaluate if a self-generated movement unfolded as planned? During the movement, the brain can use predictive strategies (known as internal forward models) combined with ongoing sensory feedback to assess any departure from the target action. However, a large part of the variability in our movements arises from central disturbances (i.e., noise) during planning, that is, before the movement has even been initiated and in the absence of any external feedback. Whether the brain can internally monitor this planning variability is therefore unclear. To address this question, we sought to test the hypothesis that humans possess trial-by-trial motor confidence about their planned movements. We developed a context-dependent motor timing task in which subjects had to implicitly use motor confidence to detect binary changes in the context and switch their behavioral strategy accordingly. Our behavioral results revealed that subjects do estimate their trial-by-trial planning variability and use the associated confidence to update their strategy across trials. By analogy with the predictive processes the brain employs to evaluate ongoing movements, we hypothesize that the ability to monitor planning errors relies on a mental forward model that uses a copy of the motor command to predictively simulate the motor plan. We implemented this idea in a neurally-plausible model for motor planning and were able to recapitulate confidence-based behavior of our human subjects. Moreover, the model made several predictions that could be verified empirically. The idea that forward models are established as early as during motor planning opens an avenue for bridging the fields of motor control and metacognition.

    ***** ***** *****

    Representations of time-dependent behavior in working memory

     

    Eli Pollock

    Ph.D. Student

    Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences

     

    One hypothesis of working memory is that objects or contexts can be represented by persistent activity in the brain. This can be modeled by dynamical systems with fixed points encoding memories. While this model is compelling, it fails to account for how the brain might hold a time-dependent stimulus in working memory. In this talk, I will discuss my work in using recurrent neural networks (RNNs) to generate hypotheses about how representations of time might be stored in working memory. I will present results from an experiment where subjects had to remember a time interval across a delay, and then reproduce it. I used a recently published algorithm to train an RNN on the same task, which provided a hypothesis with predictions for human behavior. I will also point out some limitations of this paradigm and propose some alternative ways for thinking about similar tasks.

    Speaker Bio

    Nicolas Meirhaeghe

    PhD Candidate

    Harvard-MIT Division of Health Sciences and Technology, Bioastronautics Training Program

    ***** ***** *****

    Eli Pollock

    Ph.D. Student

    Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences

    Additional Info

    Upcoming Cog Lunches:

    April 24, 2018 | Rachel Magid (Thesis Defense) - Schulz Lab

    May 1, 2018 | Josh Rule - Tenenbaum Lab

    May 8, 2018 | Kelsey Allen - Tenenbaum Lab

    May 15, 2018 | Tuan Le Mau - Brown Lab

    Upcoming Events

    Jul
    Thu
    3
    Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences (BCS)

    Akhilan Boopathy Thesis Defense: Towards High-Dimensional Generalization in Neural Networks

    1:00pm
    Add to CalendarAmerica/New_YorkAkhilan Boopathy Thesis Defense: Towards High-Dimensional Generalization in Neural Networks07/03/2025 1:00 pm07/03/2025 1:00 pmBuilding 46,Singleton Auditorium, 46-3002
    Jul
    Fri
    11
    Simons Center for the Social Brain

    Special Seminar with Dr. Balázs Rózsa: Real-Time 3D Imaging and Photostimulation in Freely Moving Animals: A Novel Approach Using Robotic Acousto-Optical Microscopy

    3:00pm to 4:00pm
    Add to CalendarAmerica/New_YorkSpecial Seminar with Dr. Balázs Rózsa: Real-Time 3D Imaging and Photostimulation in Freely Moving Animals: A Novel Approach Using Robotic Acousto-Optical Microscopy07/11/2025 3:00 pm07/11/2025 4:00 pmBuilding 46,46-3310
    Jul
    Tue
    15
    McGovern Institute for Brain Research

    Special Seminar with Liset M. de la Prida

    10:00am to 11:00am
    Add to CalendarAmerica/New_YorkSpecial Seminar with Liset M. de la Prida07/15/2025 10:00 am07/15/2025 11:00 amBuilding 46,3310
    See All Events
    Don't miss our next newsletter!
    Sign Up

    Footer menu

    • Contact Us
    • Employment
    • Be a Test Subject
    • Login

    Footer 2

    • McGovern
    • Picower
    Brain and Cognitive Sciences

    MIT Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences

    Massachusetts Institute of Technology

    77 Massachusetts Avenue, Room 46-2005

    Cambridge, MA 02139-4307 | (617) 253-5748

    For Emergencies | Accessibility

    Massachusetts Institute of Technology